Update:

I emailed Maker Geeks. I explained the situation as I did above. They emailed me back super fast and explained that I got a package intended for another client. They asked me my choice for the filament and said they would get it out immediately. I was impressed at teh speed with which they replied and offered a solution. If it comes as they said I will post another update.

They have a good reputation, and for now I will say it is earned.