It's not a problem with the printer, it's a design problem. Having small width and big height cause trouble. At some point your prints will break in half should you print something taller with the same diameter.

3/16th diameter is just way too small for an object of 2" length.

I am more surprised that you could pull something last week. Because this is the kind of parts that I tend to avoid printing, because I know it's a lost cause.

However, you might do some magic. Drop the temperature down to 200 and start blowing a fan directly on the printed parts. You have to force the PLA to solidify before it has time to warp itself and fall under the pressure from the nozzle. You have then to play with the printing speed.