As @3Dex ltd said, you will just have to try it. What you get out does depend too a large extent on how well dialled in your printer is to that filament. There is a lot of variation in diameter, for example despite what is claimed so this can greatly effect the results. Also not all filaments have the same properties, even amongst standard PLAs. The Biome 3D you speak of has a very nice finish to it so we like it a lot because of that and colorfabb are of course colorfabb and is really a go to for consistent high quality and easy printing. How polymaker will compare you will just have to see.