Looking at you o-rings my guess is that the first layer is not bonding well and the nozzle is dragging the plastic away.

Use a piece of paper and spend sufficient time to level the printing bed as throughly as you can. Lots of links and google is your friend here, including youtube vids etc.

You may also have the printing speed of the first layer way too high. Your slicer will allow you to adjust the speed of the first layer. I generally keep it down to a max of 20 mm/s for the first layer. The first layer accounts for most of the final print quality, do not try to save time there.

As to blue versus white tape, the blue tape has a surface finishing (seems like parafinic to me??) which makes a better bond. It is not the tape itself, but the finishing which is the clue here.

I have dispensed with blue tape and kapton a long time ago. I exclusively use glass and hairspray/3DLac now in all my printers with excellent results. Much easier and far better.