It's black plastic and shiny. Double whammy.

I tried coating it with flour and using the Makerbot digitizer again, after it failed with just a big glob the first time.

While the Makerbot digitizer produced something which looks similar to half of the original part, correcting the imperfections is still a large job.

Does anyone know of a service which can handle this job?

Mods: if this is the wrong place for this post, please move it.