Close



Page 4 of 4 FirstFirst ... 234
Results 31 to 35 of 35
  1. #31
    Engineer-in-Training
    Join Date
    Mar 2014
    Posts
    223
    Quote Originally Posted by WarFairy View Post
    That's not going to happen. Consequences are the fault of people, not design and engineering.
    If the design and engineering is geared towards creating and broadcasting (to call it something) a gun that intrinsically has "illicit use" all over it, without limiting who or what for is going to be used then you can't waive moral responsibility away so easily.
    It's not much different as if some chemistry enthusiast set out to teach people how to make nerve gas in the privacy of their homes with readily available materials, to explore the limits of chemistry of course...

    Seriously, if you can't appreciate the ethical implications of what you are doing you probably shouldn't be doing it.

  2. #32
    What about this design "intrinsically has 'illicit use' all over it"? Are you looking at the simple fact that it is made in plastic? The fact that it can fire .22LR rounds? Maybe it is the coloring? Anything can be misused and there is nothing in it's intrinsic qualities that makes it only for one purpose. You see a scary, bad person, gun. Others see a well thought out mechanical design. It is neither good nor evil on it's own.

    There are legitimate uses for firearms that are neither bad nor nefarious. Hopefully you never experience any of those circumstances first hand.

    Keep up the good work WarFairy. You need to move to a more friendly location so you can actually do the testing as well.

  3. #33
    Super Moderator curious aardvark's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2014
    Posts
    8,818
    There are legitimate uses for firearms that are neither bad nor nefarious.
    true - but not for an inaccurate easily concealed HANDGUN that fires 22 long rounds.

    Guns are useful tools - handguns - not so much. Plastic untraceable hand guns - yeah, only two uses really.
    1) plinking in your back yard.
    2) criminal purposes.

    Given that handguns - in general - are illegal in most countries anyway (america is JUST 1 COUNTRY - no matter how many times you slap the word 'world' in front of a purely american event, it doesn't make it so)
    What it could be used for is a moot point. Just having the .stl files on a computer would be enough to be prosecuted in the uk.
    And much as I'd like to make one, just for the sake of it. I'm not stupid enough to think the .stl downloads aren't being tracked by GCHQ.

  4. #34
    As someone who enjoys shooting (targets not people), I hope I never, ever have to pull the trigger in defense of my family.

    I see both side to the argument about 3d printed guns. Now, I see no issue with someone designing them and printing them, it is the person holding the gun that is responsible, not the maker, designer, seller, etc. (and I mean legal, not illegal). Argument that it can be used to kill people - sure it could but so can that printed knife - which by the way is actually easier to hide as you can print it with no metal parts.

    People say that it is immoral or unethical to publish / design - whatever for the gun. Yes, it is illegal in some countries but then again so is pornography. A design / print of a naked woman, body part, etc. would be illegal in many countries (I've been to them) - Warfairy lives in one. How many would argue that posting a print file for a naked woman is immoral or unethical? Can't hurt anyone with it (I guess you could but would be harder) but there are still issues with having it in many areas. Sadly in the US, this would more likely cause legislation for 3d printers than guns (we are backwards in some ways).

    In the end, if someone wants to get a gun, knife they are going to be able to get one. It doesn't matter how. If they want all they really need is a metal tube, nail, and a hammer (might not be accurate but it will work).

    Posting the design doesn't matter. Someone that wants can now take pictures of parts, turn them into a model and print. Might take a little trial and error but I'm sure there are plenty that could make a working gun that way.

    Enough rambling. People all over the world just need to get back to respecting each other, there is too much hate.

  5. #35
    I know im bringing up a 2 year old thread but im wondering what happened to this gun? Are the plans downloadable somewhere?

Page 4 of 4 FirstFirst ... 234

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •