Close



Page 26 of 26 FirstFirst ... 16242526
Results 251 to 255 of 255
  1. #251
    RobH2 that’s great to hear! Im curious if the rod version before the v-rails lends more stability. This week as I’ve been looking at newer printers to see what has been going on in the industry I couldn’t help but notice the highly praised Original Prusa MK3 uses rods.
    While I have only adjusted my x-carriage rollers, they do give some play if they loosen.

  2. #252
    Super Moderator RobH2's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2013
    Location
    Baltimore, MD
    Posts
    896
    Add RobH2 on Thingiverse
    I always assumed the rail version was more stable but I have no way to compare. I'm guessing the rail version is better though. I was planning to upgrade with the rail kit but never did. I bought this printer to do quick prototypes of items for clients. I soon found that I could order much, much better parts online as prices dropped and quality got better so I began using my printer less and less and never bought the rail upgrade kit. Now I just make parts for friends boats or cars now and then. It's still a great printer.

    I would be curious to see what the current top rated do-it-yourself printer is. Maybe it's still the Maker Farm. I just haven't researched it.
    Bambu P1S/AMS
    NVision4D http://nvision4d.com

  3. #253
    Staff Engineer printbus's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2014
    Location
    Highlands Ranch, Colorado USA
    Posts
    1,437
    Add printbus on Thingiverse
    Quote Originally Posted by CoffeeCup View Post
    ...Can you comment on your experience with your Bondtech BMG?
    Similar to RobH2, I only rarely use the printer these days - my time seems to continually get tied up in other things. With one exception, I've been pretty happy with the BMG. The big advantages are it's small, compact, and light. I do seem to have to level the print surface every time I print something, but only using the printer every few months could have more to do with that than the BMG and/or the associated carriage plate & hot end mount.

    The one thing I miss from the Greg's Wade extruder is that the BMG has no easy way to release a filament. With the Greg's Wade, I'd heat up the hot end, reverse the extruder a few mm, and then release the grip on the filament so I could pull the soft filament out without the hobbed bolt pressing against the filament. With the BMG, you essentially have no choice but to keep reversing the extruder until the filament can be pulled from the gearing. There's a access lever you can unscrew that removes one of the gears, but the filament continues to press against the rear gear. I only rarely change filaments, so it isn't that big of a deal but it is something I don't care for.

    If you opt to stick with the Greg's Wade, I'd definitely check out my remix of it. My research concluded the parts MF was shipping with the printer really weren't very optimal. The last Greg's Wade I printed was on my printer a couple of years before I swapped it out for the BMG approach.

    On the rails vs. rods, yeah I don't know which provides a more rigid approach. I opted for the MF rail approach since what I read made me want to avoid linear bearings, and one of my goals was also to minimize the use of zip ties as mechanical fasteners on my printer. Seems that most printers using rods use zip ties to hold the linear bearings in place, and I didn't care for that.
    Last edited by printbus; 02-16-2020 at 09:18 AM. Reason: damned line spacing

  4. #254
    I did see your revision to Greg Wade’s Extruder and thank you for the comments. Has there been a noticeable increase in print quality with the BMG? With the lighter weight I would assume there would be less lash/play but maybe it only comes into play at higher speeds.

  5. #255
    Staff Engineer printbus's Avatar
    Join Date
    May 2014
    Location
    Highlands Ranch, Colorado USA
    Posts
    1,437
    Add printbus on Thingiverse
    Quote Originally Posted by CoffeeCup View Post
    I did see your revision to Greg Wade’s Extruder and thank you for the comments. Has there been a noticeable increase in print quality with the BMG? With the lighter weight I would assume there would be less lash/play but maybe it only comes into play at higher speeds.
    I don't think it would be fair for me to try to address that, based on the limited printing that I've done. I also know that the filament I have now prints crappier than the filament I used to have, so there's that significant factor as well.

    As you suggest, I think the BMG approach has a lot of potential over the Greg's Wade. No gear backlash. Better grip on the filament - perhaps especially beneficial in precise retraction & recovery control. Yes, the lighter extruder, especially along with the smaller/lighter stepper motor I used should lead to a lighter carriage that is quicker to accelerate/decelerate. I remember running some mechanical tests to determine what settings I'd use, but I don't recall how the settings compare to what I used to run.

    Improving cooling airflow was a driver in the carriage redesign and migration to the BMG. I'm pretty sure the new approach provides better print cooling airflow, so that has potential for improved print results if the cooling is applied properly.

Page 26 of 26 FirstFirst ... 16242526

Tags for this Thread

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •